Opening page…
Closed
- Listed price
- $475,000
- Listed Jun 12, 2026 · $500/sq ft
- Sold price
- $465,000
- Sold Jul 27, 2026
2 beds|1 ba|950 sqft|25,578 sqft lot|1964 Built|5 MLS days on market
268 Tally Ho, Arroyo Grande, CA 93420
Property Description
Welcome to 268 Tally Ho Road in Arroyo Grande! Nestled on a spacious parcel in one of the Central Coast's most sought-after communities, this property offers the perfect blend of privacy, convenience, and small-town charm. Enjoy the peaceful setting while remaining just minutes from the vibrant Village of Arroyo Grande, local shops, dining, schools, and world-class beaches. The generous lot provides ample space for outdoor entertaining, gardening, recreation, or future customization as it is located on over a half an acre (0.587) Surrounded by the natural beauty of the Central Coast, this property presents a rare opportunity to create your ideal lifestyle in a highly desirable location. Whether you're looking for a tranquil retreat or a place to gather with family and friends, 268 Tally Ho Road offers exceptional potential in the heart of Arroyo Grande. Heres a chance to own a property right near the beautiful rural landscape of AG and be able to hope over to Grande avenue and have a straight shot to the beach. The property is currently red tagged due to flooding. Most likley needs to be all cash or renovation loan (buyer to due their own due diligence on lending)
Listing agent: Chris CucchiaraDRE #02023880chrisjcucchiara@gmail.com, Listing office: NextHome Central Coast
MLS data updated 10/27/2026, 7:32:47 PM PT
Source: CRMLSMLS #: PI26129673
Belmont insights
Price & property history
Compare recorded home prices, same-type ZIP sales and mortgage rates.
Last recorded sale$465,000
Jul 27, 2026
Available records22026
From MLS recordsActual listing and closing events
Prices use the left axis; mortgage rates use the right. Hover, tap, or focus the chart and use the arrow keys. Red SOLD badges mark recorded sales.
This home · nearest recorded event
$465,000Closed sale · Jul 27, 2026ZIP 93420 · Jul 2026
No monthly averageAt least 3 eligible sales in this month are required.30-year fixed mortgage benchmark
No weekly rateNo published rate within 7 days of this date.This home · 2 price recordsJun 12, 2026 – Jul 27, 2026
ZIP 93420 · same property typeLoading eligible closed sales…
Freddie Mac · national weekly ratesLoading mortgage-rate history…
Recorded sales in this period (1)
ZIP averages use publicly displayable closed sales from our licensed MLS feed, matched to the same ZIP and exact property type. Months with fewer than 3 sales are omitted; the current month is incomplete. Lines connect available monthly observations across gaps and do not represent measured prices in missing months. These averages are not adjusted for size, condition, or location within the ZIP, and are not an appraisal. Feed coverage may not include every sale. All available shows the available home and ZIP history, with mortgage rates over the same dates.
Mortgage benchmark: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey®. © Freddie Mac. Weekly national 30-year fixed rates, not APRs or a loan quote. Actual terms vary. Methodology changed in November 2022. The chart does not establish that interest-rate changes caused a home’s price changes.
Lines connect recorded asking and sale prices. They are visual guides, not estimates of the home’s value between those dates.
View listing & sale records
No earlier records were returned by our current sources. This does not mean the home has never sold.
MLS records may be incomplete. Earlier asking prices are not sale prices.