Opening page…
Closed
- Listed price
- $1,049,000
- Listed Nov 20, 2017 · $1,027/sq ft
- Sold price
- $1,010,000
- Sold Jul 25, 2018
2 beds|1 ba|1,021 sqft|4,000 sqft lot|1850 Built|63 MLS days on market
217 Windward Ave, Pismo Beach, CA 93449
Property Description
Located in the heart of Shell Beach, the historic Bellevue Schoolhouse is newly reborn as a two-bedroom residence with a high-end modern kitchen and other amenities. Built in 1850 near the Johnson Ranch Trailhead at South Higuera Street near San Luis Obispo, it was moved to its present location early in the last century to begin a new life as the First United Methodist Church of Shell Beach. After extensive restoration and upgrades, it was most recently used as a venue and accommodations for events at the adjacent La Perla Del Mar center next door. Saved from the wrecking ball by its current owners, this historic and proud residence is only 2 blocks from the ocean, and walking distance to restaurants and shopping in the Village of Shell Beach. Wheel chair accessible.
Listing agent: Ken TaylorDRE #00815882KenTaylorHomes@gmail.com, Listing office: Taylor Hoving Realty Group
MLS data updated 10/31/2026, 8:10:48 AM PT
Source: CRMLSMLS #: PI17261656
Belmont insights
Price & property history
Compare recorded home prices, same-type ZIP sales and mortgage rates.
Last recorded sale$1,010,000
Jul 25, 2018
Available records22017–2018
From MLS recordsActual listing and closing events
Prices use the left axis; mortgage rates use the right. Hover, tap, or focus the chart and use the arrow keys. Red SOLD badges mark recorded sales.
This home · nearest recorded event
No recordNo property-price record in this range.ZIP 93449 · Oct 2026
No monthly averageAt least 3 eligible sales in this month are required.30-year fixed mortgage benchmark
No weekly rateNo published rate within 7 days of this date.This home · 0 price recordsNo records in this period
ZIP 93449 · same property typeLoading eligible closed sales…
Freddie Mac · national weekly ratesLoading mortgage-rate history…
Recorded sales in this period (0)
No recorded sales in this range. Select All available for older records; missing records do not mean the home never sold.
ZIP averages use publicly displayable closed sales from our licensed MLS feed, matched to the same ZIP and exact property type. Months with fewer than 3 sales are omitted; the current month is incomplete. Lines connect available monthly observations across gaps and do not represent measured prices in missing months. These averages are not adjusted for size, condition, or location within the ZIP, and are not an appraisal. Feed coverage may not include every sale. All available shows the available home and ZIP history, with mortgage rates over the same dates.
Mortgage benchmark: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey®. © Freddie Mac. Weekly national 30-year fixed rates, not APRs or a loan quote. Actual terms vary. Methodology changed in November 2022. The chart does not establish that interest-rate changes caused a home’s price changes.
Lines connect recorded asking and sale prices. They are visual guides, not estimates of the home’s value between those dates.
View listing & sale records
No earlier records were returned by our current sources. This does not mean the home has never sold.
MLS records may be incomplete. Earlier asking prices are not sale prices.